Sam Edelman Women's Garret Combat Boot, Dark Brown Waterproof, 8

But I had a problem with the right foot.It’s was too tight and base had some bumps

I adore my Garret boots! Every time I wear them someone comments about how cute they are! They are super comfortable and fit true to size. I usually wear a 6 or 6 1/2 and the 6 fits me perfectly. They have plenty of room in the toe box. I have very high arches and I loosened the ties over my arch so they are a custom fit. I love them so much I bought 3 pairs! It's a bonus they are waterproof. I live in Los Angeles and didn't really think I needed waterproof boots, but with the deluge of rain this season I'm really glad I have them! I actually love to walk in these and can be on my feet all day without feeling like I can't wait to take them off! I love them!

Half size too small, not great for wide feet and high arches. Hoping to break them in, but can’t wear thick socks. But, they are gorgeous and well made. I am tough on boots and lots of snow and slush to contend with. I will update my review after a few months of wear.

These fit me well. I wear a size 6 normally and that’s what I bought. They’re a little spacious which is fine with me since my feet are a little wide. Wearing soft and thick socks bump up the comfort level. I’ve worn them with jeans and skirts/dress. They’re versatile and a cute addition to any outfit.

When I wore these, someone told me I was going to bring combat boots back in style. I love the color and they are pretty comfortable. One weird thing is that the left sole feels a little bit raised or something.

Be aware- the leather on these boots isnt high quality. And they use different pieces of leather on boots that doesn't even match. Look at these three pairs. One is smooth (but has rougher leather on the part facing in). Two other pairs have leathers that are not smooth, of varying textures. Fit is also inconsistent. First pair i got was almost painfully tight across the instep. If these boots were made with high quality leather, i could have been confident it would have stretched. But this is not high quality leather. The second pair i ordered was not so tight, but it’s like the leather hasn't been dyed enough—it looks like a dark charcoal vs black. And it’s scuffed. I’ll try one more pair to see if i can get good fit + good leather. Why do i keep trying? Because the style is so cute! And i haven't been able to find another boot with as cute a style.

After reading some of the mixed reviews I finally took the plunge and ordered these boots. Day 1, so far so good! They are comfortable, no breaking in period. They are stylish with an edgy thicker sole. I like the zipper, makes it so much easier to get in and out of. If you’re in between sizes like I am, I suggest sizing up a half size. As for the quality, the upper part looks and feels like leather. They don’t look or feel cheap (and I am picky!). I have been searching high and low and the other brands that are much more expensive did not fit as well, we’re hard to get in/out of, and did not look as cute. These boots are made for walking! Hope they last!

Very nice boot. I’m a true 9.5 but purchased a size 10. They fit great!! Quality leather.