Vionic CAROLL0017.5M Caroll Black 7.5 M

These are good-looking, soft, high-quality shoes with great support. I wanted to buy them in light pink (smooth, non-croc) but unfortunately stock was low and my order was cancelled. I'm a size 8 but order a half-size up in dress shoes since my shoe width is a C versus the more standard B-width. These felt similar to other shoes of this type I've bought before so I would say they are true-to-size. They were comfortable from the start with little to no break in and no blisters from a full day of office-level wear.

I have several pairs. Great style to dress up or down. Have worn for severalYears and can wear all day walking and my feet or back do not hurt which only a well made shoe can do for me. A salesman told me this would be the best shoe I ever bought and he was right. I have a bunion that prevents me from wearing most styles of closed in shoes and these have solved that decades old problem. The band around the top of the shoe is flexible enough that it does not bind the foot in any area and the toe box and overall shoe is very comfortable. They do not lose their shape and will fit any occasion. I could sell this style and overall my many styles of Vionic shoes fit the same comfort and support criteria. I have everything from many sandals to athletic shoes. It took me years to find stylish shoes that didn’t hurt my feet or back. I can wear all Styles for many hours. Previously impossible! EXCELLENT

Unable to wear heels anymore and needed a dressy shoe that is comfortable and supportive. This shoe is all of the above. It is a snug fit like a second skin but it truly isn’t too tight and provides needed support. I thought it might be too flat but the arch provided in the insert is perfect. After walking around in them, they truly “break in” and feel like you aren’t even wearing a shoe. Worth the investment.

I purchased these shoes with high hopes for help with the planters fasciitis I've been suffering with. Unfortunately, they didn't fit as expected. Even though the length was good the toe box was awfully narrow. I never buy wide size shoes so I feel that these shoes are just made tighter in the toe box. The Vionic shoes are beautiful and the support felt good but I couldn't handle the extra squeeze cramping my toes. The return process was quick and easy and I received a full refund in a timely manner.

Have a lot of vionic shoes. These are a replacement because my daughter's puppy chewed up my previous pair. I have them in black and navy and wear them all the time. I also have the slippers, tennis shoes and a few others. Great support. Love them.

This shoe is the single most comfortable show I have ever wornThey are true to size.

This is a beautiful shoe. I ended up sending it back because I needed something that I could wear to walk multiple miles a day. These are very comfortable but on my foot they were just a bit too tight to think that they would be comfortable after long distance. If your commute is primarily via vehicle this is a great shoe and I would totally recommend. Would give 4.5 stars if I could

Bottom line: If you need supportive shoes or have foot pain/plantar fasciitis, this shoe is good for that. Not the best, but definitely good!Nitty Gritty and Gripes: Helps with my plantar fasciitis flare ups. But the insole isn’t as significant as I would like and I almost find it too squishy. The heel is also much too tight and has cut me/rubbed blisters every time I wear them. I’ve now worn them around ten times, all day, and they haven’t loosened up.Loathe the old lady style grosgrain ribbon border. Don’t like the light pink either but it was the cheapest option. Luckily it hasn’t scuffed much, but the potential is there. Whatever nubuck or suede-like material is used inside the shoe makes my feet hot.Good news is the toe box is big enough! If you have wide feet and/or tall feet, you can wear these shoes.A little snugger in length than true to size so if you prefer looser fits, size up 0.5. Or try a different Vionic shoe.I love this brand but this flat is boring, not terribly attractive and not as wildly comfortable as the 5 star styles from the same brand.If you’re new to Vionic, I recommend starting with a loafer or sandal style before these flats.Even with my gripes it’s still a much better shoe in terms of materials and support than anything trendy. I would recommend it to friends but I would probably show them my complaints first. Maybe you have petit feet and will adore them. Remind me of clown shoes a little bit in size 10.I wear them to school and to work, and even on the weekends some of the time.