Columbia Womens Ice Maiden Slip Iii Snow Shoe, Gravel/Black, 8.5 US

I have a wide foot and was bit unsure of what size to go with because of some of the reviews saying it fit snug. I ended up just going with my normal 9.5 shoe size, and I’m glad I did. I think if I had sized up to a 10 the boot would have been too big and I would have only been able to wear it with thick socks and an extra insole. I can easily wear a thin or thick sock with these boots and be okay. As far as it being stiff, I only felt that it was slightly stiff to get my foot in when I first slipped my foot through the boot when I unboxed them. But that was to be expected. Once I started walking I didn’t feel that they were stiff in the slightest again and I could easily slip them on and off. I happened to get these right before the storm that hit California pounded us with rain, and I can say these boots kept my feet 100% dry and warm. Now having worn them all week these boots feel like butter when I put them on. The sole is super flexible and has good grip which gives them an almost tennis shoe feel, so they are not clunky at all. I don’t feel like I’m dragging my feet like when I’m wearing uggs or bear paws. My advice would be to go with your normal boot size, and only size up maybe 1/2 a size if you feel they may be tight on you. Overall it’s a really good pair of boots, at a good price.

Like it a lot

Columbia brand is usually well made. This particular boot fit was smaller than average. I always use medium or regular fit shoes. Materials appear sufficient but the sole makes a loud squeaking walking on tiles. Sole is not very pliable and hopefully it will soften with use. Noticeably still when first trying on. The toe box is more narrow than usual snow boots that accommodate thicker boot socks. The pair I received had the tag snipped off and seem to be a returned item, not a brand new pair! It was not indicated as used in description; was sold and shipped by Amazon.

Unlike some others, I find these easy to put on. I have a high instep, which is often a problem fitting slip on boots. These are easy. The shaft is quite stiff, but not uncomfortable when walking. The uppers are not the finest material but they should last ok and I was not trying to make a fashion statement. The color is a lighter tan than expected. They are warm. I used a water protectant spray before wearing outside. I wear a 7.5 in shoes and an 8 in boots, and these fit as expected.Update: I ordered another pair in a different color, since these boots are so good on slippery surfaces, and they are so easy to put on. Great deal with “used like new”.

Love the quality, the look, the warmth, the fit. I love how my foot slides into these boots without needing to pull on. The footbed is so comfortable its like an old friend. Walking is a pleasure, no binding, or discomfort. I have been mucking my horse's muddy paddock every day, and afterwards when I hose them off they come clean without wetting the inside and still looked brand new. Wow, I had been looking for these boots for about a year since my old LLBean boots started to break down at the tread. Thanks for making these boots, I purchased another pair so I will be prepared for the next 3 years. I love these BOOTS

Runs large and very stiff and clunky. Not a fan.

Fits true to size and keeps my feet plenty warm and dry.

Not only are these cute but they are so comfortable. I wear them for walking around and from day 1 they were extremely comfortable, water proof and warm. Absolutely love these.